I hope that this helps you. While I do my research I keep copies of information that might fit - just in case it fits in my family down the road. With that said - the Alice J Goucher sounded like a name I had seen or heard before. So I looked in my "Bits and Pieces" file. In there was a copy of the 1880 US Census from Alma,Jackson,Wisconsin.
Alice J. Goucher age - 17 birth year - 1863 birthpalce - New york occupation - at home relation - daugther single white female Head of Household - Richard H. Goucher Father's POB - NY Mother's POB - NY
Richard was 55 years of age at that time. Lists both of his parents being born in NY. The mother's first name is Elizabeth 53 years of age. Lists her father being born in ME and her mother being born is NY. It looks like she may be the youngest of the family.
I still don't know if they tie. However, I hope that this piece of information will help you make a tie with more past generations. Sometimes all it takes is just one missing link to find more. Good Luck.