Gottlieb and Sarah had a daughter Eliza (Frances)9/24/1836. She married Jake Showalter on 11/27/1856. She died 8/21/1900 buried at Mill Creek Brethren Their son, John Harvey Showalter, born March, 1866 was my grandfather. He was a traveling music class teacher in Virginia and Ohio. He died 11/17/1911 in Luray, Virginia.