There is one Maymie, spelled the way you did: MAYMIE HAGERMAN b. 15 Apr 1901 d. 27 Feb 1996 LR 72764 (Springdale, Washington, AR)
There are none spelled the normal way, "Mamie". You could use the advanced option to see if there was a Paul with LR Arkansas.
You may have the correct spelling. If you do, don't forget to check the other one. People named "Smythe" get recorded as "Smith" about 30% of the time, and idiots who saddle their children with "Jon" doom them to saying "No 'H', please" for the rest of their lives. It doesn't work 40% of the time; they STILL get recorded as "John". Mamie Eisienhower, Ike's wife, is the only Mamie to achieve national fame, and the US is going to spell it like her for the next century.