By the dates from your messages, I'm getting into this discussion rather late. I am a descendant of Elizabeth (Robinette) Henthorn of Perry County, Ohio, just south of Licking County. (By the way, the Licking County folks tended to use the 'Hinthorn' spelling.)
However, my purpose is to advise that I came across a copy of "The Henthorn Family . . ." by Norma Henthorn of Oklahoma and Rev. Raymond Bell of Pennsylvania. It was published in 1990 and Norma died in 1993.
I digitally transcribed the book and added some of my own "stuff". I would be happy to e-mail it to anyone who can read Microsoft Word. Regards to all, Jim