From my records I show Charles I was the son of Charles S and Jennie Warina Reynolds. Jennie was born in Willsboro, Essex, NY on 25 MAY 1861 Charles S was born on 22 JAN 1857. Jennie's parents were Steven A Reynolds and Rachel Phelps. Charles S parents were Jonathan (John) Hoag and Cylinda Doty. John was born abt 1821 and Cylinda in 1823. I have more info, Charles S had two siblings, Geroge W and Edgar L. Charles Irving brothers were George and Steve. The birth places are in questioned at this time Charles S and brothers were born in MI but son Charles I was supposed to be born in MN and WI, but as far as our family knows this is correct information. If you have any other infor that would be of help let me know. You may contact me at firstname.lastname@example.org or email@example.com.