I read the 1880 and 1900 census records for James Hodge, then checked the ancestry family trees, which has the following, perhaos something new there for you:
James Washington Hodge b 5 Oct 1840 Washington Co. Tennessee, died 10 Aug 1900 Rothwell Menifee Co KY., son of Robert Edward Hodge and Lucinda Ann Hall, b 15 June 1829 Montgomery co. KY. dau/of Edward Hall 1785, and Amelia Garrett 1787. Married #1 Mary Ann Hall b 16 Jul 1838 Rothwell Clark co. KY, dau/of Levi Hall and Elizabeth Alexander. Children: Ellen13 June 1860 Annie2 mar 1862 Robert abt 1864 Algen21 Jun 1865 George9 Sep 1867
married #2 Mary J. Hall, b abt 1848,after 1874 Ky, she d 8 Apr 1875 of Puenmonia d/o Levi Hall and Elizabeth Alexander Birdedaughter b abt 1874 KY
Married #3 Catherine before 1878 KY Wills Hodge abt 1878 Slate Menifee Co. Ky
Married #4 Clarinda Ingrambefore 1883 son Charlie b Nov 1883
Married #5 unknown.
I am not related, nor can I say these records are correct.