I am afraid you may be getting your Mary Annie Judge mixed up with my Mary Ann Judge. My great-grandfather and great-grandmother are Brown Judge and Sarah Philips, from Magherafelt, Londonderry. They moved to Scotland, where most of their children were born, and then emigrated to Pennsylvania in 1880, after which my grandfather was born (in 1881). Of the children born in Cumnock, one was Mary Ann Judge, my great aunt. She married Richard Holgate and lived in NJ and Pennsylvania. I have census records and family history, so I am sure my information is accurate. There were a lot of Judges in Cumnock; my great-grandfather was one of 17 siblings. I know that John Judge, one of Brown's brothers, also ended up in Cumnock. I wonder if there is another Mary (yours) that was born in Cumnock around the same time, to another branch of the Judge family?