Kathy, I am so happy to hear from you.Until I found the ship manifest, I didn't even know that Nicholas, John and James existed -- what a surprise.Outside of Mary's line I had not found another researcher of this Keating line, until now. How wonderful! So far, I have nothing on Edward and Nora, or James.It has been difficult knowing who I was finding because no one seems to know how old they are at any given point in time.Do you have info for all of them? Did Edward die Apr. 15, 1885? Do you live in Cincinnati? I have found their connection to Hamilton and Columbus also.I would love to see what you have, and to share what I have collected. You can contact my email:email@example.com Hope to hear from you soon.