This is awsome!I have the exact same information.I thought Mary Keefer was the the daughter of Jacob and Catherine Keefer.The Mary Keefer I have is shown as marrying Farley J. Tubbs.He is my ggreat grandfather.If this is correct, Jacob and Catherine are my gggreat grandparents, and Abraham and Mary Ann Keefer are my ggggreat grandparents. Any ideas of who the actual parents of Mary J.(Arnold) Keefer were?Was she adopted?I have a photo, post 1882 of Mary J. (Arnold) Keefer Tubbs with her 8 remaining children out of 13. Farley, her husband is not in the photo, so I assume he had already passed away.Please help.Thank you.