I was going to enter information in the Fattic Forum, but there is none.So I checked the Keesling Forum, which is familiar to me because some of my distant Noland relatives intermarried with Keeslings; probably in Madison County, Indiana.
Just in case this might help you - from the book "The Pioneers of Madison and Hancock Counties, Indiana" by Samuel Harden, 1895, reprinted 1900:
John Fattic was born in Showendon (prob. Shenandoah) Co., VA, October 29, 1830.He was married to Malinda Davis, August 27, 1851. All the children were born in Henry Co., near Mechanicsburg: Mary A., married to C.B. Swain; Henry A., married to Jennie Keesling; William B., married to Sarah Keesling; Dr. John B., married to Florence Victor of Cincinnati, Ohio.