Sorry all the way around Tom. My Benjamin F. Kerstetter was born May 1859. The Benjamin Franklin Kerstetter son of Simon P. and Elizabeth Bingaman was born after 1866. There were at least two other Benjamin Kerstetters. Benjamin son of Leonard Kerstetter and Sarah Stover was born 28 Dec 1828 in Coburn,PA. Benjamin son of Solomon Kerstetter and Barbara Zellers was born in 1834. Union Co. was formed in 1813 from 9 townships ceded by Northumberland Co. There were many Kerstetters in Union and Snyder Counties. Thanks for the reply.