Here is more on your Kilgore/Killgores from Low Gap.
1900 LOW GAP, NEWTON, AR
John H., farmer, age 25, born May 1875 AR father born Il mother born AR, married 6 years
Bytha E wife, age 27, born April 1873, AR father born GA other born AL, married 6 years, 2 children born 2 living
Sylvia S. daughter age 4, born Feb. 1896 AR parents born AR
Girta J. daughter, age 11/12, born July 1899, AR parents born AR
Jackson , farmer, age 38, born Jan. 1862 AR father born KY other born AR, married 17 years
Sarah L. wife, age 33, born March 1867, MS father born AL mother born AL, married 17 years, 7 children born 6 living
Ora A. daughter, age 16, born April 1884
Rhoda V. daughter, age 13, born Nov. 1886
Alice M. daughter, age 11 born Sept. 1888
Arthur B. son age 8 born July 1891
Earsy P. daughter, age 7 born Feb. 1893
Lennea N. daughter, age 3, born Oc. 1896
Roy B. son age 9/12 born Aug. 1899
all children born AR father born AR mother born MS
Nancy, head, age 61, widow, born March 1839 MO parents both born TN, 16 children born 13 living
Wayd H. son age 23, born June 1876
Prussy J. daughter, age 21, born Nov. 1878
Mary A. daughter, age 20 born Feb. 1880
Belle D. daughter, age 19, born Feb. 1881
Rufus, K. son, age 17, born Sept. 1882
Ulsses S. son age 15, born Nov. 1884
all children born AR father born KY mother born MO
Isaac C. miner, zinc ore, age 32, born April 1868,AR father born K other born AR
Susan C. , wife, age 25, born June 1874, AR father born MO mother born NC,married 11 years, 7 children born 3 living
Ulysses, son age 6 born Dec. 1893, born
Henry, son age 5, born April 1895
Dorothy, daughter, age 1, born Jan. 1899
all children born AR father born AR other born AR
Even though the places for mother's birth were different for the Killgore men, I thought they might all be brothers so went to 1880 to see.
I found the family with Nancy as the mother so it seems her sons or whoever gave the info did not know where she was born.
1880VAN BUREN, NEWTON, AR
Rubin age 43, farming born KY parents both born KY
Nancy J. age 41, keeping house, born MO parents borth born TN
Isom, son age 20, farming, born AR
Jackson, son age 18, helps on farm, born AR
Marian, daughter, age 14, helps on farm, born AR
Isaac, son age 12, helps on farm, born AR, cannot write
Cinthia A.daughter, age 10, helps keep house,born AR, cannot read or write,
Albert, son age 8 born AR
Ambrose, son age 6 born AR
John, son age 5 born AR
Waid H. son age 4 born AR
Perusa J., daughter, age 2, born AR
Mary A., daughter, age 1, born AR
all children show father born K mother born TN (the enumerator just put ditto marks under the third column which they should not have done as that was parents of Nancy not of the children.
So if Nancy had 16 children and 13 were living in 1900 they were:
Isham, John, Jackson, Isaac, Wayd, Prussy, Mary, Belle, Rufus, Ulsses and 3 others.
1880 had also - Marian, Cinthia, Albert, and Ambrose for a total of 14 known children - 2 unknown.
1870 JACKSON, NEWTON, AR
Reuben age 31, born IL
Nancy age 29 born MO
Jonathan age 11, born AR
Isham age 9 born AR
Jackson age 8 born AR
Marion age 4, born AR
Isaac, age 2, born AR
Cintha age 6/12 born AR
1860 WAR EAGLE AND WALNUT, BENTON, AR
KILGORE (in index as Kilyere)
Rubin age 23, farmer , born KY
Nancy age 20 born O
Jonathan age 1, born AR
Isom, age 3/12 born AR
** I wondered about Jonathan - is he one who died young? He is not in the 1880 and later census years and they named another son John in 1875. Iwondered if he died between 1870 and 1875.
Nancy seemed to have a child about every two years so there may have been one born between Jackson and Marion that died??
I took a look at ancestry.com family trees and found a few - one has a whole list of the children of Reuben and Nancy as:
John Henry 1875-1937
Waid "Hamp" 1876-1961
Pruvia J 1877 -1939
Mary A. 1879-1946
They have marriage date of March 18, 1858 LaRue Benton, AR for Reuben and Nancy.
Also birth: Reuben Shelly Kilgore Jan. 8, 1837 Trigg Co. KY died March 7, 1898 Newton Co. AR
father : Jonathan Kilgore,born 1810,mother: unknown Indian
Nancy Jane Roseberry born March 3, 1839 Newton, AR died May 10, 1908 Newton, AR - father: Isom Roseberry, mother Elizabeth
They don't show any sources for any of the info so take from it what you will. I doubt that Nancy was born Newton, AR, as all census show her birth place as MO
They do show a total of 16 children which is what the census says Nancy has.
I hope this helps you.