Thank you for responding. I guess I'd best go to Schoharie Co., NY for this information. I wonder if the 1850 census could clarify some of this information - I don't think Helen Margaret Nethaway and Peter Kilmermarried until 1851 or 1852, but Peter Kilmer's family with his 1st wife might be listed. I had hoped to be able to clarify Rev. Kilmer's information in his book. Will keep searching.