Linda, thank you for the info. I hope we can help each other more on this case. It's a good possibility that James and Lue Vaughn's neighbor in 1880 Putnam CO. TN, E R KANARD (Kinnaird?), is Lue's father.E R's son John R. is about right age to be husband of James' sister Laura Vaughn. In the 1900 Census for Putnam Co. TN, there is a Russie KNARD (John Russell?) and Larra (Laura Vaughn Kinnaird?) and family, with elderly father-in-law Amos Vaughn (James and Laura Vaughn's father) living with them. Also, in the same household is Russie's 13 year old sister Mattie F? Please let me know if you find Lue's correct full given name. My Aunt said part of it is Louise.