Samuel Loree (Loring) from Southold, Long Island, New York was born before 1686.He married Hannah (Forgerson?).She died in Southold on March, 1739.He died about one month later on April 15, 1739.
Samuel and Hannah had the following children: John, Jeremy, Ephriam, Job, Samuel, Hezekiah, Sarah, and Hannah.John, Job and Samuel all moved to Morris County, NJ in the late 1740's, early 1750's.
I am fairly certain that the same Jotham does not occur among the descendants of Samuel Loree. Job Loree had the most children, but most removed to Canada after the American Revolution. Hezekiah moved to southern NJ and had a large family.
I suggest that you might look among the children of Hezekiah and John Loree for your Jotham.Darrell Loree might be able to help.He posts on this site.