Cindy, I finally got reply from ST raphael (archives in Cinci). Not too much info and very faded. However, it did show Catherine Lynskey and Michael Eagleton married on May 19, 1863. I did not know if you had that info or not.
I found my GGM Catherine Lynskey's family in Syracuse and went to visit them in Sept. Shared lots of info and photos. Do you know names of your Catherine's parents? I am sure we must be same line. I need to get info in order and get to Chuck Lynskey to connect.
Hope the little bit of info is of use to you.
My husband and I want to take a cemetary visiting trip to look up family, but with cold coming, will have to wait until Spring.