I thought I would post this list of possible findings between the Mattingly "guru", William Mattingly and some things I have found. Perhaps something will fall out of the tree that hasn't been seen before.
I believe that the Catharine on the Catherine Miles gravestone may have been a misspelling. Everything else I have seen so far is Catherine with an E. I also have a page in my old 1840 bible which I believe is her signature. It is spelled with an E and her marriage license also has the spelling with an E.
I have in my notes about George and Catherine’s children about the same as you had. I won’t relist them all here, but below are some additions or differences:
For Miles Philip Mattingly, George and Catherine's son, I have Miles Pius Mattingly based on my father’s verbal history as well as a letter from Cynthia Naylor who happened to be working on a different family name history. It lists Miles Pius Mattingly as George’s son.
I have T. Mattingly as Thomas J. Mattingly b. 1834
I have F.K.Mattingly b. Abt 1836 as Francis Kendrick Mattingly b. 29 Jul 1836
Martin Spalding Mattingly b. Abt 1844 as Martin S. Mattingly b. 27 Sept 1843. (Just a closer date)
Emma Christina Mattingly is listed as Christina Emily in my notes.
I am more inclined to believe your notes here as I have little documentation.
For some reason I had Joseph Marion Mattingly listed as George Marion Mattingly. Thank you for that. I changed my notes here to match yours as I believe this was clearly an error on my part.
Nora Cruse and Miles Mattingly marriage has:
Notes for NORA JEAN CRUSE: Listed as Nora J. on the 1900 census of Owensboro, Daviess County, Kentucky and residing with her parents.
Nora J is actually Nora Queen Cruse according to the birth certificates I have. Her father was Joseph E. Cruse and mother was Eleanor Queen. His name I understand was originally spelled “ Crews” before coming to the U.S.
Children of MILES MATTINGLY and NORA CRUSE are: i. MILES PHILLIP MATTINGLY III, b. 19 Nov 1915, Daviess County, Kentucky. Actually spelled as "Philip". Died 5 Nov 2002 in Louisville, Ky.(My Father)
ii. DANIEL E. MATTINGLY, b. 19 Dec 1917, Daviess County, Kentucky.Died. 1 Aug 2001 in Louisville, Ky.(My Uncle)
iii. NORA Q. MATTINGLY, b. 02 Sep 1920, Daviess County, Kentucky.I have her listed as Elnora Queen Mattingly, (my Aunt)
iv. JOHN D. MATTINGLY, b. 14 Nov 1925, Daviess County, Kentucky. The D stands for David.