I live in Lawrence, IN. My Great Grandfather was Robert P. McCoy and Great Grandmother Elizabeth Warren McCoy. They are burried in the cemetary here near my home. I have the memorial book from Roberts funeral. He was born Jan. 8, 1849 and passed on August 16, 1936. Roberts father is listed as John Noble McCoy and I have located some records which indicate he was born in Indiana around 1816. J. Noble McCoy was married to Sarah Elizabeth McCoy. She was born in either Kentucky or Ohio but I don't know her maiden name. There is too much of a coincidence for there not to be a connection with you post. If you could e-mail me maybe we can help each other. Thanks.