According to a Memoriam written for Catharine McDill wife of Col. John Noble, she died 12 April 1867 in Columbus,OH. The article says she was born at Funkstown, on Antietum Creek, near Hagerstown, MD Aug. 15th, 1793.Her father was Isaac McDill and died when she was quite young.Her mother was Catharine Wagoner.
In the 1790 census, the only Catharine McDill in Washington County, MD was the head of the household. No Isaac is listed. Also, there is guardianship record in Washington Co. which does not name Catharine McDill as a child of Isaac.The record is dated 25 June 1792.Isaac is said to have died Dec. 1791.How could this Catharine, b. 1793 have been a daughter of Isaac and Catharine McDill?
Washington County, Maryland Guardianship Bonds, Film # 0014665, SLC Copied Feb. 23, 2005, Lewiston, ID branch Library, pg. 45
Washington County State of Maryland to wit: Know all men by these presents that we Catharine Mcdill. Alex Clagett & John Cagett, are held and firmly bound unto Mary Mcdill, John Mcdill, Margaret Mcdill & Susannah Mcdill the heirs and representatives of Isaac Mcdill, late of said County Deceased, in the penal sum of Eleven Hundred & Seventy four pounds, Six shillings & two pence specie, to which payment well and faithfully to be made and done, we bind ourselves our and every four heirs Executors & administrators ? the whole and for the whole jointly & severally firmly by these presents Sealed with our seal and dated this 25 day of June 1792
The Condition of this Obligation is such that if the above Bounden Catharine Mcdill Administratrix of Isaac Mcdill late of said County Deceased do and shall well and truly satisfy and pay unto the above named Mary Mcdill, John Mcdill, Margaret Mcdill & Susanah Mcdill, or the survivors or Survivors of them, his her or their heirs Executors or Administrators their, his, or her part or proportion of the above named Isaac Mcdill ? Estate.That is to say to each of the above Named heirs the full and just sum of One hundred and forty six pounds fifteen shillings and ten pence half penny specie with Legal Interest for the same from the 17 day of December 1791.At the time they respectively arrive at Lawfull age to receive the same, then this Obligation to be Void else to remain in full force and Virture in law. Catharine McdillSeal Alexn ClagettSeal John ClagettSeal
The 1860 census of Franklin Co., Ohio shows Catharine Noble age 67, b. MD.