It's possible that no one's directed you to this page on Genealogy.com:
He includes this entry: "Peter Meurer b 1825 Nassau Prussia d 1881 Lanesville IN"
Hope this helps! Meurer (or "Mason") is a much more common name across the water. My dad came over in the 1950s, so it's unlikely we're related to that particular Christian Meurer, unless we have a common ancestor (we're mapped back to the early sixteenth century at this point).