Thanks for the reply but it seems unlikely thay your Frank Muldoon is the same. Very little is known about him but one of my cousins (Franks grand daughter)told me that she thought Frank was an attorney and that after he died, the family tried, unsuccessfully, to get custody of daughter Reta. If, indeed, that is true, then Frank wouldn't have been around in 1915. However, maybe my story has holes in it and they divorced rather than he died. How old was your Frank in 1900 when Reta was born? My grandmother was 26 at the time.