My gggg grandfather was Henry Niedig who had (at least) three children, John, Daniel and Nancy. John, my ggg grandfather, was born in 1824 in Stark Co, OHIO. The dates, names and locations all match up to your family. Perhaps Daniel and David are the same person. Lovina, daughter of John, is my gg grandmother.
Here are three generations down from Henry Niedig as I have them so far:
Descendants of Henry Neidig
1. Henry Neidig sp: Elizabeth 2. John Neidig (b.1824-Stark County Ohio;d.11 Jan 1898-Deshler,Ohio) sp: Elvina Price (b.10 Jun 1826-Pennsylvania;m.1 Feb 1844;d.11 Jun 1900-Ohio) 3. Elizabeth A. Neidig sp: Michael Herrick 3. Cynthia Neidig 3. Alfred Neidig sp: Sophia 3. Sevilla Neidig sp: Frank Roberts 3. Millie Neidig (b.17 Jun 1864-Wharton,Ohio;d.24 Sep 1947-Findley,Ohio) sp: Winfield Scott Cole (b.10 Jul 1846-Blanchard,Ohio;m.5 Oct 1882) 3. Lovina Neidig (b.May 1846-Massilon,Ohio;d.17 Oct 1921-Malden,Missouri) sp: Amos Stricker (b.Nov 1839-Whartonsburg,Ohio;m.12 Aug 1862;d.4 Aug 1919-Deshler,Ohio) 3. Levi Thomas Neidig (b.14 Aug 1856-Wyandot County;d.23 May 1906-Wyandot County,OH) sp: Minnie Belle Bruce (b.1865-Highland Co.;m.31 Jan 1890) 2. Daniel Neidig 2. Nancy Neidig