I'm not sure.I have that same birthdate for my John Noggle.I have no idea who his parents were.He was born in Adams Co., PA, lived in New Springfield, Mahoning Co., OH, and then moved to Allegan, MI.He married Mary Agatha Hoffmaster (Hofmeister) and they had:Mary A. b. 1832; Abraham b. 1834; Sophia b. 1837; Susannah b. 1838; George Frederick b. 1842; Sarah B. b. 1844; Christiana b. 1846; Elizabeth b. 1848; Absalom b. 1850; Nellie b. 1852; and Theodore Jacob b. 1855.There must be some connection.