You're my cousin somehow, My Nolting line also comes from Knox County, Indiana, and I still have PLENTY of relatives there (just a few "Noltings" left)but I don't see the names you provided linking up to mine. Anyways, My line goes Cyrena Nolting (Grandmother)- Earnest Nolting (G-Grandfather)-August Nolting (GGGrandfather) and finally Henry or Heinrich Nolting (GGGGrandfather) who came from Northern Germany.
Any connections? Do you have more names? we can try to link up.