Helen, I have a subscripton to ongreatfamily and that is where I got the information.My husband's grandfather was James Elbert Oiler.He lived and died in Cleveland. According to onegreatfamily, his father was James D. Oiler.He was born Dec. 13th 1828. He was married to Eva Shipley who was born in 1814 and died 1887.They had 2 children together, Mary Stepheny born about 1856 and Marth Ann born 1857.Eva died 1887. He must have married Missouri Dodrill(1850) died 1923 almost immediately because their first child was Ada born 1888 and my husband's grandfather 1891 James Elbert. That means that James D was about 60 when his children were born which is verified by my father-in-law son of James Elbert. Accordingly my info says that Eva was married to Jacob Bard, born 1812 died 1849.According to web site they had 5 children together.