I don't go on Genforum often enough, otherwise I would have found this before now.
Eileen, the Jonathan you are looking for was probably the son of the Jonathan that Crystal is talking about.Jonathan and Mary Mathews were married in 1814 in Kentucky and later moved to Spencer County, Indiana.My ancestor was Nancy Overlin, who was, I think, their daughter. You will find Ancil, Tapley and others in Spencer Co. IN.There are several other Overlin's there. I will look out what I have and send it to you, after you answer this post.Want to make sure you are still monitoring the board. Peggy