According to the 1880 census, P. John Paar (married to Margaretha) was born in Prussia (about 1852) with parents born in Prussia. If your Peter Paar didn't come from Prussia... how do you explain this??
I'm not related to the Paars of Ohio either. All of ours came from NY and live/d in IA, mostly.
This is the information that the family gave me:
My Marcus Charles Paar (born 1979) is the son of Ronald Charles Paar (born 1955) married to Rita Jean Witucki (also having Christopher Benjamin and John David). Ronald (brothers Robert, Richard and sister Jean) is the son of Marcus Robert Paar (allegedly also went by the name Marcus Ernest Paar. born 1917 died 1994, married 2 times. Once to an Elizabeth Albano and the second to a Mary).
Marcus Robert/Ernest Paar's father was Marcus William Paar (he also went by Max, born 1871 died 1938) married twice once to ?? (having 4 children Peter, Alfred, ??, and Margert?? ) and second to a Mary O'Leary (having Marcus Robert/Ernest 1917, William 1911, and others ???). However, if this is true he would've been 46 at the time of Marcus Robert/Ernest's birth (by Mary O'Leary).
Marcus William Paar is the son of Peter Paar and Rosalia Guttsokalk (1897-1923)
I tried your listed email here and it didn't work. Mine is Meretisa@yahoo.com. Thank you so much!! The family will be ecstatic if this is us!!