I agree. From what I've read Peddock (Paddock) Island was "discovered" in 1638, which, in my own opinion, is really late in the game. I think that it was founded much earlier too. I also wonder if Leonard was Robert Paddocks' ride to America. That would also make sense. Robert isn't listed on any other ship's manifests so Leonard would be a obvious choice. Leonard may have also communicated to Robert the need for a blacksmith in the new colonies. A blacksmith was crucial to survival and was deemed a high ranking person. Since Robert's first wife died he could marry a new wife and go to the colonies. It would have made him prosperous.