My ancestor Owen Palmateer b. 1852 is the son of John Palmateer the son of John D Palmateer born in 1791 Dutchess County. John Palmateer was married to Anna Phoenix. John died around 1855 Anna remarried Martinus Houghtaling. In the 1860 census Owen and his siblings are listed under the name Houghtaling in Delaware County. Owen married Carrie Worden about 1880, he remained in Delaware County until about 1910.