Hi Lori, I just happened to find this site and was also looking to find out more about the Papay genealogy. Not a very common name it appears.My Greatgrandfather was also from Hungary. Lived in NY then moved to Michigan. My Grandmother (his daughter) is still alive. She was an only child and I've never met another Papay. I have a friend (ex-coworker) who's last name is Papai. Probably from the same family way back. I wonder if Papay was Americanized from Papai.