Jonathan was bondsman for the marriage of Reuben and Ann Pitcher in 1822 and I have that Jonathan died in 1830. The horse thieving trial was in Fayette county in 1808. Unless Jonathan was caught again and hung in 1830 I don't see how it could be. Reuben, I thought died in MO. That is your area. One of the things I discovered recently was that Margaret, Joannah's daughter owned the property in Mercer CO. Ky where they lived, not her husband Levi Dearinger. Joanna also owned 3 acres in Woodford county near the KY river. I'm not absolutely sure about when the Peachers let VA for KY. Joanna always gave her birthplace as VA on the census and the horse thieving trial was in 1808 in Ky so I am estimating there. I am going to Ky in a couple of weeks and if I find anything new I'll let you know.