Could you please tell me where you got the last name for Nancy Eggins.
A good friend of mine (Esther), found the marriage Reigistrations for Benjamin Phoenix to Nancy and it's not the same as your Eggins.She is listed as Anne Hebner when she is listed as the mother to son Joseph at his birth in Scott twp, ONT. and as Hannah Evener (or Hebner sp?) on her marriage to Benjamin Phoenix both of Markham and as Hannah Hebner on her Death Registration in Brown Hill North Gwillumbury.
You probably have all you need on this line by now but I do have some Cem. info. on Phoenix and Lietch if you still need it.