I have a Pitcher who seems to have followed a similar path and had a grandson that used Orrin as his name.
Nathan Pitcher 1782-1-27-1865.From what I have found he was born in MA, a number of his children were born in NY--we think possibly around Henderson. They later went to IL and finally settled in approx 1848 in Delaware County IA.
His Grandson was named Nathan Orrin Talmadge son of Nathan and Mary Pitcher Talmadge.
Nathan Pitcher married Polly (possibly real first name Mary) Lavina (1787 -9-11-1875) their known children other than Mary above were Harrison Pitcher Emeline Pitcher Wilcox Syble Pitcher Crosier