Hi Theresa, You mentioned Eunice's sister, Elizabeth.Do you have any firm information about her marrying Marshall Wheaton, and if they had any children, and when he may have died?
If she did marry Mr. Wheaton, I believe Elizabeth may have had a second marriage to Shevah Houghton, and they moved to New York with Elijah Pitcher. Some of their children lived near Elijah Pitcher and his sons.
Shevah was a Revolutionary soldier and they had a large family together. My husband descends from him.
One Pitcher researcher had Shevah as a female, and married to what he said was Elijah Pitcher's son, Ellis. I have that marriage record, and it is my male Shevah. I believe Ellis was an abbreviation for Elizabeth.
Is there any proof that Elijah had a son named Ellis? I think he had a brother who married an Ellis woman, and they named their son Ellis Pitcher.