According to the Plumlee research I have done, there was an ABRAHAM D. PLUMLEE who married SARAH ANN BUTLER on 18 Feb 1844 in Anderson Co., TN.They are known to have the following children:
Nancy Elizabeth Plumlee, born cir 1845, Knox Co., TN; Md. W. C. Biggs. Martha M. Plumlee, born cir 1849, Knox Co., TN. James Columbus Plumlee, Sr., born cir 1850, Knox Co., TN; Md. twice, first to Salina ______, second to Delila A. ______. Joseph L. Plumlee, born cir 1852, Knox Co., TN. William E. Plumlee, born cir 1855, Knox Co., TN. Sarah F. Plumlee, born cir 1859, Morgan Co., TN. Abraham Plumlee, born cir 1861, Morgan Co., TN. Thomas Wesley Plumlee, born cir 1863, Morgan Co., TN.
James Columbus Plumlee had at least 7 children.I will send you a separate E-mail containing what I have on this family.
I do not show all the children that you mentioned, but I am probably missing some of the children.This is not a Plumlee line that I have researched very much.
Maybe this will be the same family you are seeking.