My wife is a Poffenbarger. I have Elias as marrying three times, Rosanna McCreary 1835,Catherine Martin 1847, Catherine clark DuVall 1850.Elias b. 28 Dec. 1817 in Berks Co., Pa. Baptised al Atlahala Luth. Church.Parents David and Barbara P. David also on same church baptismal records. Elias marries Catherine DuVall 14 Nov. 1850 in Preble Co., Ohio and dies 1867 in Ohio.My wifes line is from there. Believe third marrage to Catherine Clark DuVall is second marrage for Catherine. I do not have death date of Catherine Martin.