The name Gideon Putney occurs in a list of taxpayers in Warrensburg NY about 1815. I also have a Mariah Beswick of Bolton who married a Joseph Putney. Does the following match your records:
Generation No. 1
1.Gideon1 Putney died in Warrensburg NY.
Child of Gideon Putney is: + 2 i. Joseph2 Putney.
Generation No. 2
2.Joseph2 Putney (Gideon1) was born 1.He married Mariah Beswick 13 May 1844.She was born Abt. 1812 in Bolton NY2.
Children of Joseph Putney and Mariah Beswick are: 3 i. Joseph3 Putney2. + 4 ii. Caleb Putney, born Abt. 1846; died Abt. 1868 in Bolton Warren NY.
Generation No. 3
4.Caleb3 Putney (Joseph2, Gideon1) was born Abt. 1846, and died Abt. 1868 in Bolton Warren NY.He married Arvilla Feltt in Bolton Warren NY.She was born 9 Apr 1846 in Keene NY3.
Children of Caleb Putney and Arvilla Feltt are: 5 i. Clarence Eugene4 Putney, born 5 Apr 1869 in Bolton Warren NY. 6 ii. Clara Putney, born 16 Mar 1873. 7 iii. Wesley Albert Putney, born 23 Jan 1878 in Bolton Warren NY; died 24 Apr 1879. 8 iv. Ada Mariah Putney, born 30 Sep 1880 in Bolton NY4. 9 v. Charles Leslie Putney, born 27 Jul 1884 in Bolton Warren NY.