PYE, John & Lydia HIRKY, 19 May 1831, m by JGE, b Henry Youtsey, Campbell Co., KY
Henry Youtsey was cousin of Jane Orr Culbertson belo. John Pye was brother of Capt. Wm Henry Pye - Campbell Co., KY, also below.
PYE, William H. & Jane Orr CULBERTSON, 1 July 1837, m by EG, b Robert Culbertson, Campbell Co., KY
I am certain that John and Lydia Pye traveled to Indiana near Indianapolis from old Youtsey family journal - they were in Missouri before the period you discussed with some Mormon involvement, then returned to Indiana.
There was another person involved, Aaron Hart, married to Issabella Pye, sister to both John and Wm. Any knowledge of this party?
Brother Wm Pye was supposedly born in Ohio (not verified). If this ties, glad to help.Your info in return appreciated.