You definitely are on the right track. I have a complete genealogy on my John Read line. In it contains the names of your Israel line that you mentioned. Hopstill Holbrook did marry a Samuel Reed. Our last name went from Read to Reed and I noted yours Reid. There is rich history of John Read coming to USA from England and with the Rev, Samuel Newman and others purchased and settled what is now Seaconk, MA but back then it was Rehoboth, MAThey started a settlement called The Rim and started a church. The Newman Congregational Church there at present is the offspring of the original. I have visited the church and found the lot of John Reed in the cemetery across the street.