Thank you for your response. I belive that my Catherine is the oldest daughter for John and Elizabeth, she was born in 1825 and married in 1842. And it makes sense that they might have named their eldest daughter after his mother.
Please email me with any specifics on the cemetary as I would like to drive up to Monroe while I have some time off during the holidays. Alternatively, please forward my information to the person who originally supplied the directions and ask if they would be willing to get in touch with me.
I tried to email you privately but I'm not sure that it went through. Thank you so much for your response. I'm thrilled to have this information.