I would love to share information with you. I am trying to find out where the Redners came from. I don't think they are the same Redners as the Reddenhauser/Reddenaer/Rednor/Redner line that came from Germany around 1660. These are also the Redners you find in Canada. Right now I am looking at John Redner and Hannah Wilson as possibilities for James Redner's parents. They were married in 1798 in Orange County.
Do you have the first name of Laurence Gibney's wife? Where did they move to, or did they stay in Monroe? Did the family move to NJ? This information might help me to figure out if we are the same family, and where other Redners from Orange went to.
Some of my line of Redners had moved to Wanaque, Passaic, NJ, where my father was born. There are a lot of Redners burried there. I now live in NC.
My dad and I have spent years on this. It is a tough line to research.