I looked at an older post of yours that showed the William belonging to Timothy O as definitely dying in 1828, in other words the William whose will our Samuel witnessed. But others of that line have argued with me that he died in 1833.Can we prove the 1828 death date for William, son of Timothy O.? Amd also, if that works out, could someone have put the wrong Samuel in as Timothy O.'s son? I just feel like that William is the right William, and the location and time, and the various surnames involved; I can't get away from it, and yet if that Samuel was born in 1789 and is the one I keep following, something is wrong somewhere.