I betcha we got a match. In our tree we have a Ralph Holme born in 1897 in Detroit who married a Freda Catherine Roofe in Detroit. You know, Phoebe is a weird name like Freda is a weird name. I got a feeling they are sisters. We got Detroit in common and the same time period. The only other informatio we have is that Ralph and Freda had four children: Clyde, Richard, Marion, and Betty Lou, all born between 1918 and 1934. But so far we haven't found any of their lines. So I think we have a clue: look for a Detroit Roof or Roofe family with siblings Phoebe, Freda, and Charles. Just a hunch. But they pay off sometimes.