Well, I think we have made a connection.I just found the information about the marriage.Robert F. McNay, b. 1843 in KY, age 22, and a farmer married Lucretia I. Routt, b. 1845 in KY, on 21 Mar. 1865. Father: Columbus Routt born in VA, Mother ? (you just provided) born in KY.Married by Rev. Marcus Arnold (This Arnold is in my Arnold family in Pendleton Co.)I don't know if you would be interested in the McNay line in which Belle married.You might want the names of her children though. I believe we can be pretty sure she died around 1879. I have the Barton papers around here somewhere that mentioned the two brothers in the civil war.I believe it said they were killed.As soon as I find it, I will let you know.Isabella was in Campbell Co. in 1870, which is a stone's throw from Covington.Thank you so much for reponding to my posting.I have information from another Routt researcher who had a Columbus in his line, but the father was Peter Routt.Don't know if they are connected or not.