Timewise, Mary would fit in a lot better with Isaac Salls and 1st wife Peggy Doubleday. SOMEWHERE I have some notes on this Crosby-Salls marriage but I cannot locate it right now. Do have you further details to enlighten me with?
I have not researched this branch in many years -- but I don't have in my files (that I can find) info on the other Doubleday. Are you saying that Phebe/Phoebe, 1st wife od Sam Hawley was a Doubleday as well?