Yes, I'm disappointed, too, that we're talking about two different guys.I have a notation in my 'Mystery Schwenks' file about a Conrad, though, and I hope it's of some help to you:
Conrad Schwenk, b. Abt 1784-1790, married Maria Catherine Dewald.Children: Sarah Schwenk b. 16 Jun 1814, d. 15 Apr 1877 @ Schuylkill Haven Conrad Schwenk, Jr b. abt. 1816
I believe this Conrad and (Maria) Catherine lived in Schuylkill County.As you can see, they could easily have had a child born in 1809.:-)
You may also have luck if you place a query in the Schwenk mailing list.The list owner, Kathy, and one of the subscribers, Tim, both have Conrads in their lines.To subscribe to the list, just send an e-mail to SCHWENK-Lfirstname.lastname@example.org with the word 'subscribe' in the body of the message.