Found earlier posts that the parents of Barbara Shively were Barbara Eshelman and Benjamin Shively. Unable to find any parents for Benjamin Shively. Have found a Benjamin Shively married to "Barbara"...but that turns out to be his first cousin whom he married and where there is plenty of documentation that they are a separate couple.
Also unable to identify the parents of John Taylor, other than a reference that his father may have been "Philip Caleb Taylor". But that's become something of a dead-end, too. Any help greatly appreciated.