George, I have not researched the Philip Shively (son of Christian Shively)line except for the Daviess County Shively's.I will share information that has been compiled by others but ask that you use this information only as a guide and check the information for yourself.From the information others have shared I have: Philip Shively served in the War of 1812. Please use caution with his children because he was married 3 times:1) Susanna Lewis m 9-Apr-1800 Jefferson Co KY Book 1, Page 362) Elizabeth Bartlett m 31-Oct-1804 Jefferson Co Ky Book 1, Page 493)Phoebe Logan m 9-Apr-1814 Jefferson Co KY Book 1, Page 79. (If you find birthdates for the children then you can always match the dates for the marriages to determine the mother). Children include: 1)Susan 2)John L. B. Shively one source says he was born ca 1807 so we might check that his mother was Elizabeth Bartlett. 3)Philip Shively 4)Hugh Linsey Shively 5)William V Shively I do not know what the initials in John L. B. Shively's name are. Hope this serves as a guide to help your research.