My great grandmother was a Shively from Knox, Columbiana, Ohio. I had pictures of the family, but not much information. Caroline Josephine Shively, b. 2 Mar 1869 daughter of: Robert Shively, b. 5 Sept 1833 and Phyetta Knaus, b. 2 Jan 1839I have name for other Shively's in the area, but no way of connecting Robert to them. Does anyone know who his father may have been or any other information? Thanks!