Rufus Franklin Shue married Eliza Jane Taylor (dau. of George and Narcissa) on 20 Feb., 1865 per Pope Co., AR marriage Book D, page 101, but the 1870 Census p. 235 (Narcissa Taylor head of household, Dwelling #1039) shows Eliza and 2 children living with Narcissa and her other children. (I believe Narcissa lived in Illinois Township of Pope Co. at that time.) The 2 Shue children were Nancy E. b. @ 1866, and William M. b. @ 1868.Rufus was no longer with his wife and children at that time.Eliza later married William J. Walls in Conway Co., AR on 28 Aug. 1881 per Conway Co. Marriage Records.
I am curious about the conflicting information you have about Eliza.Let me know if you need more info.I don't have a lot, but I do have a little more I can share. Was Rufus or Eliza your ancestor?